Is Our Chicken The Same As Grocery Store?

written by

Jared Frye

posted on

May 20, 2024

With the addition of chicken we’re getting tons of questions about our chicken and how it compares to other chicken you can buy, which we love! 

Recently, someone was telling me they had been buying organic chicken from the grocery store, and now were going to be buying our chicken. They asked about pricing and the comparison between our prices and grocery prices. They asked, “your chicken isn’t really different than organic chicken in the store right?”

Whoa. Hold on!

Now to be fair, I’m pretty sure they meant it as a compliment that our chicken was on the level of something with organic certification.

We’ve covered before how many loopholes there are in food labeling, and some of the misleading statements….and you’ll be shocked to know that organic certification has its own set of loopholes.

Of course, in order for any product to be labeled as certified organic, it must adhere to the rules put in place by the USDA. Certified organic guidelines for all meat production require that the animals are fed 100% organic and non-GMO feed and forage (yes that means organic beef isn’t necessarily grass-finished beef), not given any growth hormones or antibiotics and have the ability to graze on organic pasture.

Before I go much further, all of this information is available on the USDA’s website – there’s a ton of information there. This handbook from the USDA is a good place to get started if you want to dig into it! NOP Handbook | Agricultural Marketing Service (usda.gov)

Back to certified organic – according to the guidelines, it turns out that chicken is exempt from the requirement that they graze on pasture. Per the USDA, “maintaining vegetation cover is a challenge” when it comes to raising poultry.

So, is organic chicken required to be raised outside on pasture? Not according to what I’m reading!

Organic chicken is supposed to have “access to the outdoors and direct sunlight”. Remember what we found with the misleading label of “free-range” chicken? What’s that mean? It means industrially raised birds are still raised inside large barns and are only provided access to the outdoors, sometimes in the form of just a “pop hole”….so they can’t even get their whole body outside. 

So, if organic chicken is required only to have “access” to the outdoors, are they falling into the same loophole as free-range and only have to be able to poke their head out if they want?

Based on those basic guidelines…

  • - Fed organic & non-GMO feed
  • - Not given any growth hormones & antibiotics
  • - And only have “access” to the outdoors & sunlight

How easy would it be to produce chicken in large quantities, in a big industrial barn, and still be able to label it as certified organic?

Still with me?

I’m sure this one has ruffled some feathers (sorry couldn’t help that pun!). I know lots of people who live and die by the organic label.

And let me be clear, I’m not slamming organic labeled food. There are some great local farms doing organic right. (Here's a great place to search for them Home Page - Real Organic Project)

So, what’s the purpose of even writing this email?

Labels are misleading. Claims are misleading. Even certifications can be worked around with the loopholes out there.

Find out where your food comes from! Talk to the farmer. Ask questions and be comfortable with the answers before you decide you want to purchase those products.

That’s part of why I’m always encouraging you to email with questions, or just corner me at the farmers market!

I want you to be 100% comfortable and excited about the products you buy from us. No, we’re not certified organic. But we do work really hard to raise and produce the cleanest, healthiest meats that we possibly can – and we’re very open about our practices, so you always know where your food is coming from and how it was produced.

If certified organic is important to you, I think that’s great. A quick google search will help you find any certified meat or vegetable producers in our area…find them, and go talk to them. If they’re a small farm like us, they’re probably doing it right. But don’t take my word for it, go ask them and get comfortable with where your food is coming from!

Okay, putting my soapbox away for now!

More from the blog

The Secret to Perfect Pork

The Secret to Perfect Pork

How to Cook Pork Without Drying It Out (Simple, Foolproof Guide) If you’ve ever said, “I don’t cook pork because it always turns out dry…” You’re not alone. It’s probably the most common thing we hear. And the truth is—you’re not doing anything crazy wrong. You’ve just been taught the wrong way to cook pork. The Real Reason Pork Turns Out Dry For years, pork was cooked to very high internal temperatures. Why? Because older production systems carried a higher risk of foodborne illness, so the advice was simple: Cook it until it’s well done. The problem is—that advice stuck around long after the industry changed. And what it created was a generation of overcooked, dry, flavorless pork. The First Rule: Stop Overcooking It Here’s the key: 👉 Pork is perfectly safe at 145°F (with a short rest) That means: Slight blush of pink? Totally fine Juices still in the meat? That’s what you want When you cook pork to 160°F+ like many people still do, you’re squeezing all the moisture right out of it. Use a Meat Thermometer (Seriously) If there’s one tool that will instantly improve your cooking, it’s this. No guessing. No cutting into the meat. No “I think it’s done.” Cook to temperature, not time. Pork chops / loin: Pull at 140–145°F, rest to finish Tenderloin: Same range Ground pork: 160°F (this one’s different) This alone will fix most dry pork problems. Don’t Skip the Rest This is where a lot of people lose it at the finish line. When pork comes off the heat, the juices are still moving. If you cut into it right away, all that moisture runs out onto the plate. Let it rest: 5 minutes for chops 10–15 minutes for larger cuts That’s how you keep it juicy. Choose the Right Cooking Method Not all cuts should be cooked the same way. Quick Cook (Hot & Fast) Best for: Pork chops Tenderloin Method: High heat Short cook time Don’t overdo it Low & Slow Best for: Shoulder (Boston butt) Picnic roast Method: Low temperature Long cook time Breaks down connective tissue → tender, pull-apart meat Fat Is Your Friend One of the biggest mistakes people make is trimming too much fat or avoiding it altogether. That fat: Adds flavor Helps retain moisture Protects the meat during cooking Especially with pasture-raised pork, that fat is where a lot of the flavor lives. Simple Cooking Method That Works Every Time (Pork Chops) If you want a go-to method, here it is: Pat chops dry and season generously with salt and pepper Heat a cast iron skillet until hot Sear 2–3 minutes per side Add butter, garlic, and herbs Baste for another minute or two Pull at 140–145°F Rest 5 minutes That’s it. Juicy, flavorful pork—every time. One More Thing: Quality Matters If you’ve only ever had grocery store pork, you might already be at a disadvantage. Pasture-raised pork: Has better fat distribution Holds moisture better Has more flavor to begin with Which means when you cook it properly… it really shines. The Bottom Line Dry pork isn’t a pork problem. It’s a cooking problem—and an easy one to fix. Cook to the right temperature. Let it rest. Use the right method for the cut. Do that, and pork goes from “risky dinner choice” to something you actually look forward to cooking. Ready to Try It the Right Way? If it’s been a while since pork made it into your weekly rotation, now’s a good time to give it another shot. You might be surprised how good it actually is.

Read more
The Truth About Pork: Why Pasture-Raised Changes Everything

The Truth About Pork: Why Pasture-Raised Changes Everything

The Truth About Pork: Why Pasture-Raised Changes Everything If we’re being honest… pork doesn’t always get a fair shake. Beef and chicken tend to be the “safe bets.” They’ve built a reputation around strength, health, and clean eating. Meanwhile, pork often gets lumped in with overly processed products and questionable sourcing—and over time, that’s given it a reputation it doesn’t really deserve. Because the truth is, real pork—raised the right way—is one of the most nutrient-dense, flavorful, and versatile meats you can put on your table. The difference comes down to one thing: How it’s raised. Not All Pork Is Created Equal Most of the pork people are familiar with comes from confinement operations. Pigs raised indoors, on concrete, with limited movement and a uniform diet designed for efficiency—not nutrition. That system produces pork that’s: Lower in nutrient density Higher in omega-6 fats Lighter in color and milder in flavor And over time, that’s shaped how people think about pork. But that’s not how pork was meant to be raised. How We Raise Pork (And Why It Matters) On our farm, pigs live outside—on pasture and in woodlots—where they can do what pigs are meant to do. They root. They forage. They move. Their diet includes: Grasses and roots Acorns and natural forage Bugs and insects A balanced, non-GMO grain ration That lifestyle changes everything about the meat. Not just in how it tastes—but in how it nourishes your body. The Nutritional Difference Pasture-raised pork isn’t just different in philosophy—it’s different on a nutritional level. You’ll find: Higher omega-3 fatty acids (the same beneficial fats found in fish) More vitamin D from natural sunlight exposure A better omega-6 to omega-3 balance, supporting heart and brain health Higher levels of key nutrients like B vitamins, zinc, and selenium And when it comes to lean cuts like pork loin or tenderloin, you’re getting protein levels comparable to chicken—just with more flavor and satisfaction. Let’s Clear Up the “Pork Isn’t Healthy” Myth Pork didn’t earn its reputation overnight. It came from years of eating pork that was: Raised in confinement Fed a limited, grain-heavy diet Processed and preserved in ways that stripped away quality But when you step back and look at pork raised on pasture, it’s a completely different food. Clean protein. Balanced fats. Rich in nutrients your body actually needs. The problem was never pork. It was how pork was being raised. A Return to the Way It Used to Be Not that long ago, pork was a staple in nearly every household. Families relied on it for: Flavor Versatility Long-term nourishment Lard was a trusted cooking fat. Bones were used for broth. Nothing went to waste. That wasn’t a trend—it was common sense. And now, more people are starting to come back to that way of eating. Why Pork Deserves a Place on Your Table If you’re looking for a protein that works for everyday meals, pork is hard to beat. It’s: Versatile (chops, roasts, sausage, ground) Flavorful without needing much added Nutrient-dense and satisfying Often a more practical option for feeding a family A few simple ideas: Cast iron pork chops with butter and herbs Slow-cooked pulled pork Breakfast sausage made from real ingredients Cooking with lard instead of highly processed seed oils It’s the kind of food that fits real life. Taking It a Step Further: Nose-to-Tail Eating On our farm, we believe in using the whole animal. Not just because it’s efficient—but because it’s the right thing to do. That includes: Bones for broth Organs like liver and heart Fat rendered into lard These parts are some of the most nutrient-dense foods available: Liver – rich in vitamin A, B12, and iron Heart – contains CoQ10 for energy and heart health Bones & marrow – packed with collagen and minerals This is how people used to eat—not out of necessity alone, but because it made sense. The Bottom Line Pork shouldn’t be the “forgotten meat.” When raised the right way, it’s: Clean Nutritious Flavorful And deeply connected to the land it comes from Our pigs play a role in improving our soil, rotating through pasture, and helping us leave things better than we found them. And the result is pork you can feel good about feeding your family. Ready to Try It for Yourself? If it’s been a while since pork made it into your weekly rotation… this might be the time to bring it back. You might just find it earns a permanent place at your table.

Read more
Return To Top